ЗОШТО МАКЕДОНСКАТА КНИЖЕВНОСТ Е ОТСУТНА ОД ЗАПАДНИОТ КАНОН НА ХАРОЛД БЛУМ?

Authors

  • Гоце Смилевски

Keywords:

Harold Bloom, literary canon, Blaže Koneski, small languages, antithetical criticism

Abstract

This paper examines the absence of Macedonian literature from The Western Canon: The Books and School of the Ages (1994) by Harold Bloom, setting Blaže Koneski's essay "Writing in a 'Small' Language" against Bloom's project. Bloom's canon rests on several principles, among them strictly aesthetic selection, originality understood as "strangeness," Shakespeare as canonical measure, and the sublime as the aim of reading. Applied consistently, these criteria could well admit into the Western Canon Macedonian authors whose oeuvres satisfy the principles cited. Yet the lists in the Cataloguing of the Canon, comprising nearly nine hundred authors, contain no Macedonian author, nor any representatives of the Albanian, Bulgarian, Slovenian, Romanian, Ukrainian, or many other national literatures written in so-called "small" languages. The paper argues that this absence reflects three factors that Bloom himself acknowledges: the accidents of personal taste, the impossibility of authoritatively surveying the canon after 1800, and the shortness of a single human life for reading everything of aesthetic value.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Конески, Блаже. (2022). „Пишувањето на ’мал‘ јазик“. Целокупни дела на Блаже Конески. Том 12. Прилози за современиот македонски јазик. Критичко издание во редакција на Катица Ќулавкова. Приредиле Елена Петроска, Станислава - Сташа Тофоска. Скопје: МАНУ. 569–572. [Koneski, Blazhe. (2022). „Pishuvanjeto na ’mal‘ jazik“. [“Writing in 'a small' language”]. Celokupni dela na Blazhe Koneski. Tom 12. Prilozi za sovremeniot makedonski jazik. Kritichko izdanie vo redakcija na Katica Kjulavkova. Priredile Elena Petroska, Stanislava – Stasha Tofoska. [Coplete Works of Blazhe Koneski. Contributions to the Contemporary Macedonian Language. Critical edition edited by Katica Kjulavkova. Prepared by Elena Petroska, Stanislava - Stasha Tofoska] Skopje: MANU. 569–572. (In Macedonian.)]

Bloom, Harold. (1997). The Anxiety of Influence: A Theory of Poetry. 2. edition. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bloom, Harold. (1994). The Western Canon: The Books and School of the Ages. New York and San Diego, London: Harcourt Brace & Company.

Brebanović, Predrag. (2011). Antitetički kanon Harolda Blooma. Beograd: Fabrika knjiga.

Stojmenska-Elzeser, Sonja. (2017). “The Controversies of The Western Canon by Harold Bloom.” Proceedings of the ESIRDP International Conference: English Studies at the Interface of Disciplines: Research and Practice. Editors: Bekar, Mira; Maleska, Kalina; Stojanovska-Ilievska, Natasha. Skopje: Ss Cyril and Methodius University in Skopje. 77-82.

Published

2026-11-18

Issue

Section

Literature in Intercultural Context

How to Cite

ЗОШТО МАКЕДОНСКАТА КНИЖЕВНОСТ Е ОТСУТНА ОД ЗАПАДНИОТ КАНОН НА ХАРОЛД БЛУМ?. (2026). Philological Studies, 24(2), 251-267. https://journals.ukim.mk/index.php/philologicalstudies/article/view/5646

Most read articles by the same author(s)